The Different Types of Caveat on Property That You Should Know!

Ever wondered how a legal warning can affect your property rights in Malaysia? What does it really mean when a caveat on property is filed, and how does it impact your property dealings? Whether you're purchasing a home, selling a property, or securing a loan, understanding caveats is crucial in ensuring your rights are protected.

In Malaysia, caveats on property play an essential role in safeguarding interests and preventing unauthorized actions. In this article, we’ll explore the different types of caveats, who can file them, and what happens once a caveat is lodged in the context of Malaysian property law.

What is a Caveat on Property?

A caveat on property is a legal notice that serves to protect an individual’s or entity’s interest in a property. When a caveat is filed, it prevents the property from being sold, transferred, or mortgaged until the issue behind the caveat is resolved. In Malaysia, caveats can be used to safeguard various rights, such as a buyer’s claim, a lender’s security interest, or even a dispute over a contract.

Essentially, a caveat acts as a form of protection, ensuring that the property cannot be dealt with in a way that would compromise the interests of the person who has lodged the caveat. Whether you are buying, selling, or lending, understanding the role of a caveat on property is crucial in safeguarding your legal rights and ensuring that no unauthorized transactions take place.

Types of Caveats on Property in Malaysia

In Malaysia, different types of caveats can be filed depending on the nature of the claim or interest in the property. Understanding the different types of caveats is crucial for anyone involved in property dealings to ensure that their rights are protected. Below, we’ll explore the various types of caveats that can be lodged on a property in Malaysia.

1. Purchaser’s Caveat (Section 327 of the National Land Code)

A purchaser’s caveat is typically lodged when a buyer has entered into a sale and purchase agreement (SPA) but has yet to complete the transaction by transferring the title of the property. This type of caveat serves as a notice to the public that the property has been contracted to a buyer, thereby preventing the seller from selling the same property to another party.

When is it used?

• When a buyer has signed the sale agreement but the transaction is incomplete.
• To prevent the seller from selling the same property to another buyer before the completion of the sale.

2. Lender’s Caveat

This type of caveat is lodged by a lender (usually a bank or financial institution) against a property to secure its interest in the property. This caveat serves as a protection mechanism for lenders to ensure that their mortgage rights are not interfered with during the property transaction. It is typically registered when a loan has been granted to the property owner and the property is used as collateral for the loan.

When is it used?

• To protect the lender's interest in the property, especially when a loan is granted with the property as collateral.
• To prevent the property from being sold without the lender’s consent.

3. Contractual Caveat

This caveat is filed by a party to a contract, especially when there is a contractual dispute related to the property. For instance, a person who has a right of first refusal or an option to purchase a property may lodge a caveat to secure their right under the contract, preventing the property owner from selling or transferring the property to another party without first giving them the opportunity to fulfill the terms of the agreement.

When is it used?

• When there is a contractual right or option regarding the property that the filer seeks to protect.
• To prevent the property owner from transferring ownership without honoring the contractual agreement.

4. Judgment Creditor’s Caveat

A Judgment Creditor’s Caveat is filed by a party who has won a court judgment against the property owner. Once the creditor has obtained a judgment from the court, they may file an involuntary caveat on the property to secure the amount owed to them. This ensures that the property cannot be sold or transferred until the judgment debt is paid.

In Malaysia, the caveat provides a form of legal protection for the judgment creditor, ensuring that the property owner does not dispose of the property to evade debt repayment. It is an important tool for enforcing court decisions related to debt collection.

5. Private Caveat

A Private Caveat is lodged by an individual or entity claiming an interest in the property, even if they do not have a formal legal or contractual claim. This could be used in situations where someone has a pending legal issue or claim tied to the property, such as a pending contract or agreement that has not yet been finalized.

In Malaysia, a private caveat serves as a legal notice to others that the person lodging the caveat has a potential claim on the property, preventing the owner from transferring the property without addressing the claim. It is typically used when there is a dispute or unresolved issue related to the property.

6. Involuntary Caveat

An Involuntary Caveat is filed by a third party, such as a creditor, to secure a debt owed by the property owner. This type of caveat is often lodged when the property owner is unwilling or unable to voluntarily resolve the debt. The involuntary caveat ensures that the property cannot be sold or transferred until the debt is settled.

In Malaysia, this caveat is an essential tool for creditors who need to secure their claim against the property. It serves as a protection mechanism for creditors, ensuring that the property owner cannot dispose of the property without first addressing the financial obligation.

7. Caveat by a Beneficiary of a Trust

A beneficiary caveat is filed by a person or entity who has a beneficial interest in a property but does not hold legal title to it. For example, this may be relevant when a property is held in trust, and the beneficiary has a claim to the property. This caveat ensures that the property owner cannot transfer the property without acknowledging the beneficiary’s interest.

When is it used?

• When an individual has a claim to the property through a trust but does not hold the legal title.
• To prevent the legal owner from transferring or selling the property without the beneficiary’s consent.

Who Can Lodge a Caveat on Property in Malaysia?

In Malaysia, there are several parties who have the right to lodge a caveat on a property to protect their interests. These include:

Property Buyers and Purchasers

Anyone with a contractual interest in a property, such as a buyer who has made a deposit or signed a Sale and Purchase Agreement (SPA), can lodge a caveat. This ensures that their rights are protected, especially if the transaction has not been fully completed.

Lenders and Financial Institutions

Banks and mortgage lenders often lodge a caveat to secure their financial interest in a property. This caveat remains in place until the mortgage loan is fully paid off, ensuring that the property cannot be sold or transferred without clearing the debt.

Contractual Claimants

Anyone who has a valid claim related to the property, such as contractors, vendors, or suppliers with unpaid debts, can file a caveat to secure their rights. This ensures that the property cannot be dealt with until the claim is resolved.

Judgment Creditors

A party that has obtained a court judgment against the property owner may file an involuntary caveat. This serves as a legal notice to prevent the property from being sold or transferred until the judgment debt is paid.

What Happens After a Caveat is Lodged on a Property?

After a caveat is lodged on a property, it serves as a public notice that someone has a legal interest in that property. Here’s what typically happens next:

Prevents Property Transfer

The caveat ensures that the property cannot be sold, mortgaged, or transferred until the issue raised by the caveat is resolved. This protects the rights of the person who lodged the caveat, preventing unauthorized transactions.

Legal Obligation to Notify the Property Owner

Once the caveat is lodged, the property owner must be notified. If the owner wishes to proceed with any transaction related to the property, they must first address the caveat, either by resolving the underlying issue or by applying for a court order to remove the caveat.

Resolution or Court Intervention

If the issue that led to the caveat is resolved, the caveat can be withdrawn. However, if the dispute persists, the party who lodged the caveat may need to seek a court order to have it removed. The court will determine whether the caveat remains based on the merits of the case.

What Happens if You Enter a Caveat Without Legal Basis?

Filing a caveat on property without a legitimate legal basis can lead to significant consequences. In Malaysia, lodging a caveat without grounds is considered an abuse of the legal system and can cause unnecessary complications for the property owner. Here’s what can happen if you file a caveat without a valid claim:

• Court Action for Removal: The property owner has the right to apply to the court to have the caveat removed. If the caveat is found to be unjustified, the person who lodged the caveat may be required to bear the costs associated with the removal.
• Potential Legal Penalties: Lodging a caveat without legal grounds can lead to legal penalties. The person who filed the caveat may face fines or other legal consequences for misusing the caveat system.
• Liability for Damages: If the caveat causes financial harm to the property owner, such as preventing the sale of the property, the individual who filed the caveat may be liable for damages. The owner may seek compensation for any losses incurred due to the unwarranted caveat.

Caveats Over Land: What Are They?

In Malaysia, a caveat over land is a legal mechanism used to protect an individual’s or entity’s interest in a property. When a caveat is lodged against a piece of real estate, it serves as a public notice that the property cannot be transferred, sold, or dealt with in any way without addressing the interest of the party who filed the caveat. This process is crucial for property buyers, lenders, and anyone with a legal claim on the land.

Caveats are a powerful legal tool in property transactions in Malaysia, offering protection for both buyers and sellers. Understanding the different types of caveats, who can file them, and what happens once they are lodged can help you make informed decisions about your property dealings. Whether you are purchasing a property, securing a loan, or resolving a legal dispute, lodging a caveat can safeguard your interests.

If you’re uncertain about filing a caveat, it's always a good idea to consult with a legal professional to ensure that your rights are protected and the process is carried out correctly.

Other Article:

• Johor-Singapore SEZ: 22 Initiatives Driving Growth and Property Development
• 7 Things Tenants Can Do When Management Ignores Broken Facilities
• The 5 Hidden Costs of Owning a Home in Malaysia